Lead Sources and Costs
Paid Leads in Sugar Land and Southwest Houston: Cost per Closing and Follow-Up
Updated
Bottom line: A paid-lead closing costs the share of commission you give up on the deal that closes, plus the follow-up hours on every lead that never did. The fee and the conversion rate set the bill.
What share of the commission does a paid lead take?
Two numbers set the price of a closing from a paid lead. One is the share of commission you give up. The other is how many leads it took to reach that one deal.
Mike DelPrete reported in February 2026 that the Zillow Flex success fee held at 35 percent for years. It then went up to 40 percent in six markets.
Mike DelPrete also found the fee runs on a graduated band tied to average home value, as Zillow computes it. In all but two of those markets, the average fell in the highest band, at 40 percent.
Before you sign, ask for the Flex rate that applies to Sugar Land and southwest Houston in writing, with the date on it.
HousingWire wrote in May 2025 that no referral fee is standard, though about 25 percent of the receiving agent's gross commission is customary. The same guide puts the usual range at 20 to 35 percent.
How many paid leads does one closing take?
Rubenstein, quoted by HousingWire in September 2020, put historical industry lead conversion at about 0.5 to 1 percent.
In the same HousingWire article, a lead generation company tells customers to expect 1 to 3 percent of a month's leads to transact within 120 days of that month.
At either range, most leads you pay for never close. One closing carries the fee on that deal and the hours spent on every lead that did not convert.
Keep the count per source: leads bought, contacts made, appointments set, closings. The fee is set before the lead arrives. The conversion rate is the number your follow-up can move.
What does the follow-up on a paid lead look like?
One agent in that HousingWire piece, Keeton, runs a seven-day follow-up plan for prospects. He changes the method across the week, a voicemail one time and a text another.
A Realtor.com guide published on RE/MAX News in June 2024 advises setting how often you follow up, and what you send, by where each person is in the buying process.
Pacing by stage means a buyer touring this month gets a different cadence from one still reading listings. Both are on the same paid lead bill.
Where does the tracking and follow-up work go at Keller Williams Southwest?
At Keller Williams Southwest, the office at 1650 Highway 6 has 14 people behind you, covering marketing, technology, a productivity coach and compliance.
Weekly one-on-one coaching is where the per-source numbers get read. They sit against a yearly business plan reviewed every month, so a source that stops converting shows up early.
Office strategy is set by a 12-agent Associate Leadership Council, and that seat at the table is open to producing agents.
Bring a year of your lead-source numbers to a first conversation with Jana Hayes, Team Leader and Operating Partner. We go through the cost per closing with you, source by source.
Filed under the team.
Questions & answers
What do Sugar Land agents ask about this?
What did the 2025 class-action complaint say about Zillow Flex fees?
HousingWire reported in September 2025 on a class-action complaint over Zillow's Premier Agent and Flex programs. According to that report, the filing states that a Flex agent must pay Zillow up to 40 percent of the agent's commission. Those are claims made in a complaint. A Zillow spokesperson told HousingWire the company plans to vigorously defend itself against the allegations.
Treat the filing's figure as the plaintiffs' statement of a ceiling, with its date attached. It is not a rate set for any one market. For your own numbers, use the rate in the Flex agreement in front of you. Get it in writing before you accept any referral, and note the date you received it.
Do calls and texts to online leads have to follow TCPA rules?
Yes. The Realtor.com guide published on RE/MAX News in June 2024 tells agents to keep their communications with online leads compliant with TCPA guidelines. A paid lead gets calls and texts from the first hour, so the rule applies from the first message. The consent and timing details belong with your broker's compliance staff before a campaign starts.
Compliance is one of the roles on the staff at Keller Williams Southwest. Bring your call scripts and text templates to them before an automated sequence goes live. A review before launch costs you an hour. A sequence fixed after it has already gone out to a month of leads costs far more of your week.
Why does the first contact on a paid lead matter so much?
HousingWire cited a figure from NAR in September 2020: 75 percent of buyers interview just one agent during the home search. On a paid lead, the agent who reaches that buyer first may be the only one interviewed. A reply to a new inquiry belongs on the same schedule as your appointments, never saved for the end of a long day.
In a high-volume week, new inquiries compete with showings, negotiations and closings. The one that waits is the one most likely to interview somebody else. Read response time in your weekly one-on-one coaching, next to appointments set. Where it slips, that is the task to hand off before any other.
What moves a referral fee above or below 25 percent?
HousingWire's May 2025 guide says the fee can vary with the referral source, the location and the complexity of the transaction. Those factors shift where a given referral lands. The guide treats 25 percent of the receiving agent's gross commission as customary, while adding that the referral business has no standard rate.
Settle the percentage in a signed referral agreement before you take the client, with the date on it. That fee comes off the gross commission. Put it in the same cost-per-closing line as any paid lead's success fee. Then two sources can be compared on the same terms.